Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2020

A Small World



I always marvel at what we call science.  I am not referring to a collection of knowledge that is catalogued in textbooks, but rather the dynamic collective intellect that lives in the minds of its practitioners, able to adapt like a powerful fluid, tackling tough problems and seeking to understand the most profound puzzles of the universe and existence.

Science is built on a world-wide network of individuals who have a passion for the truth and work tirelessly in its pursuit.  Much of the work is done in solitude, with occasional interactions with others that leads to new ideas and insights that diffuses through that network.  This global mind greatly exceeds that capacity of the sum of its parts.

This morning I got an email from a senior colleague that reminded me of my privilege of being a small cell in this magnificent organism.  That email included two photos of me as an undergraduate working at Fermilab in the summer of 1977.  In those formative early years, my mind was drinking that wonderful nectar of physics at the quickest rate ever and built the foundations that I continue to call upon.

The work at Fermilab might not seem all that glorious.  I strung cables through conduits under hot, dusty and humid conditions, operated cranes that moved multi-ton detectors, cut my hands while working sheet metal to shield the detectors and calibrated photo tubes.  The point of it all was to study the interactions between quarks, and that made the work glamorous in my mind.

In today's post-fact world, this email reminded me of the glorious bubble in whcih I live, only occasionally surfacing to be disgusted by current events.  Below is that email and the photos are shown here to the right.  The only correction is that I was an undergraduate at the time, not a grad student.

To all my fellow scientists, I appreciate you all!






On 3/26/2020 4:30 AM, Manolis Dris wrote:
Dear  Mark, I  remember  you  from  my  years with the Univ. of Pa.
I  was stationed at Fermilab, working in the group of  the  late  Walter Selove.
I returned to Greece 1980.
I retired several years  ago from the National Technical Univ. of  Athens. I  work with the ATLAS experiment at  CERN, now  not  much.
I  am Professor  Emeritus (my  age  77+  years). I  remain  at  home  and  decided to organize  some  of  my  old  photographs.
I  found  your  name  from Wallter Kononenko (UPenn).
I  have  two  pictures of  you  one  with Larry Cormell and  the  other  with  me (my  face is  not  visible).
I  remember  you  as  a  young  man with a  laugh in  your  face. I  noticed  from  your  resent  photo in  your  site that your laugh is  till with  you.
Congratulations  for  your excellent carrier. BRAVO.
I  have  always problem how  to  explain to  students about  photons as  quanta (localization etc) etc
I  advised them  to  wait till  they  learn more  about quantum optics so  they  will  be  able  to learn  little  more. Most  of  us  know  something  about  the  subject
from general physics  and classical more or  less optics.

I  am  proud  to know  you.
Keep  up  the  good  work.

Manolis  Dris

 
 
Dear Manolis,

    Your email has really brightened my day!  Our University is
    basically shut down due to Covide-19, so we are all working from
    home; how wonderful that we can communicate around the world by
    email.  It's nice seeing my younger self and amazing to me that I
    did not look as tired as I recall feeling after working so many
    hours with so little sleep.
  
    I am 61, getting close to 62, and still working.  Physics continues
    to be my passion.  How many people can love what they do after so
    many years?  It must have been great fun working on the ATLAS
    experiment, which had such profound results!
   
    Incidentally, my first graduate student was from Greece and she
    stayed in the US, eventually becoming a senior director at a large
    biotech company.  Hopefully someone will send her future self a
    picture from grad school.  Small world...
 
    I am so happy hearing from you and wish you all the best in the
    future.

 
    Best Regards,

    Mark   
 
-- 
Mark G. Kuzyk
Regents Professor of Physics
Meyer Distinguished Professor of Sciences
Washington State University
Pullman, WA 99164-2814

Phone: 509-335-4672
Fax: 509-335-7816

Web Page: www.NLOsource.com

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Teaching Creationism and Intelligent Design as Science in Public Schools

About a month ago I got a Linked-In notification of a post on the American Physical Society group about a White House petition to ban the teaching of Creationism and Intelligent Design as Science.  Being an educator who takes science literacy seriously, I happily signed the petition.

The petition was motivated by the relentless push of fundamentalists to teach Creationism and Intelligent Design as part of the Science curriculum in public schools.  I was surprised by the criticisms posted in response to the petition.  Below are the critical comments and my response.

You are trying to ban free speech. This is not an issue of free speech. The petition would only ban the teaching of Creationism and Intelligent Design AS science in public schools.

Not everything true is science. Science is a method that has been shown to be incredibly successful in understanding and controlling the material world.  Because Creationism and Intelligent Design do not provide falsifiable hypotheses, they are religion not science.  It is disingenuous to teach religion as science.

If science is all one can teach then education is reduced to propaganda.  We should only teach science in a science class.  There are plenty of non-science classes in the public schools.  Nobody is calling for only teaching science, though I think we need way more science education.

Who controls what is science?  Nobody controls science.  It is not a hierarchical system like a church where rules are handed down from authority.  Scientists pose hypotheses and do experiments to test hypotheses.  Once a huge body of evidence explains many things in a simple way, it is elevated to the status of a theory.  Scientists gather theories and distil them into books to help others learn what is known.

I know a number of big science personalities that act as bullies against even other scientists for any idea that is not pure status quo. The status quo is routinely turned on its head as new evidence accumulates.  A scientist may be protecting his or her turf, but the community as a whole moves (sometimes glacially) in the direction that evidence takes it.  Many of the greatest ideas were proposed by young whipper snappers, which have become the basis of many of our most successful theories.

Banning the theory of creationism and ID sounds inconsistent with the scientific method. Scientifically we don't ban theories, we simply conclude that the theory is not supported by experimental results.Scientists are not banning Creationism and Intelligent Design.  The petition specifically bans only the teaching of Creationism and ID as science.

Wow, it is a bit disturbing to know that there are those who think that banning ideas is in harmony with our Constitution. Many have heard that old saying, "The church is a refuge for scoundrels". That truism is even truer for "science". Indeed, before condemning the teaching of "Creationism" in schools, one should feel some obligation to define "science". It most controversial discussions, the subject being discussed is never succinctly defined. Science has a precise and hopefully universally-known definition which is well stated on Wikipedia as follow: Science (from Latin scientia, meaning "knowledge"[1]) is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe.[2][3][4] In an older and closely related meaning, "science" also refers to a body of knowledge itself, of the type that can be rationally explained and reliably applied. A practitioner of science is known as a scientist.

It is said history repeat itself. This petition remember me the French revolution and the campaign waged by the radicals to dechristianize France under the same banner, the age of reason and how Maximilien Robespierre delivered his speech in the festival of reason (The Cult of Reason), and also remember me the Stalinists when their leader Stalin said: "There are three things that we do to disabuse the minds of our seminary students. We had to teach them the age of the earth, the geologic origin, and Darwin's teachings". In both cases the radicals used the same tool to eliminate their opposing views, they used the power of government.  Science has determined the age of the earth, describes its geological origin, and understands the evolutionary process.  Each of these areas meets the definition of science.  The fact that some ruthless individuals in the past advocated for science is irrelevant.  Also, the goal of the petition is not to use government to snuff out religion, only to not teach Creationism and ID as science.

I won't be signing. Why get involved in debates about the unprovable? Evolution (of new species) and creationism/ID are all unprovable. I see a magazine cover on the news stands this week with Bill Nye "fighting" for evolution - I guess - he likes to debate the ID folks, but he can't prove anything either. Science never proves anything.  However, there is overwhelming evidence for evolution that has met rigorous scientific testing, so scientists accept it.  It is a false dichotomy to say two propositions are equivalent because they or both not 100% provable.  In these cases, the preponderance of evidence is used to make the choice. 

 I'm afraid if this banning happen we are going to end up with the burning of the books of creationism and ID in Washington, D.C. and the professors who insist to teach creationism and ID are going to be arrested (because it is illegal), just like what happened in Germany in May 1933. I mean the Nazi book burnings.  The petition does not prohibit the teaching of Creationism and ID, only teaching these topics as science in public schools.  It is frankly insulting to equate Nazis with those who defend science education.

Today's great theory is tomorrow's folly! The question whether our reality came about through creation or evolution is characteristically a 19th century question. Today, with our understanding of relativity and our technological advances, no scientist would ask such a question. However, the fact that there is a large body of scientists and creationists still asking and fighting over such a question, is a subject of keen scientific investigation in itself. For that reason, we cannot ban hypotheses. It's a very unscientific thing to do. The fact that lots of people are fighting for Creationism is not a sign that there are legitimate scientific issues that remain unresolved.  Creationism is not science because it offers no testable hypotheses.  The fight is between science and those who do not like where the evidence is leading.

Stating the earth is flat is not fraud in my opinion; it is inaccurate and lacking critical scientific evidence and completeness. Creationism and ID are not amenable to test under the scientific method and therefore not fraud to state in public--you cannot disprove or prove scientifically the existence of God. Why do you jump to conclusions and say it is falsehood. How do you know the context that creationism or ID is presented in every classroom where it is done. Because Creationism and ID are not amenable to scientific tests, it should not be taught as science.  This is not an issue of fraud.  At least the flat earth is a local approximation to a sphere but Creationism and ID do not overlap with anything that is testable.

Facts are debated before the are established. Many theories and dogma that were believed to be fact have been discarded in the past when new information displaced them. Why should Creationism/ID be any different? The truth here is that you are being even more dogmatic than the Creationists/ID whom you are trying to ban. They are not advocating the banning of science or evolution. They just want equal time for their dogma, theory or whatever....truth shall prevail. The scientific method itself is dogma that needs to be scientifically validated from time to time as we learn more about our reality. I learned the scientific method and I learned creation. Today I am in a position to make arguments for or against either of them....they both have "issues". Do you want future generations to be ignorant simply because you fall on one side of the argument? Asserting that "Creationism/ID is not science therefore should not be taught in a science class" Is equally foolish because the scientific method knows nothing sacred. Everything is subject to investigation. I would doubt that Francis Bacon or Karl Popper would agree that there are any subjects which are "out of bounds" for scientific inquiry.  Science is not a dogma, but a way of gathering information that leads to a body of knowledge that is objectively true, in the sense that its elements are testable and reproducible.  Creationism and ID are dogma that cannot be tested.  Competing scientific hypotheses deserve equal time, but Creationism and ID are not science so should not be presented as a competing scientific view.  Popper and Bacon would disagree with you.  Popper proposed that only falsifiable propositions are testable, and religious dogma is not.  Similarly, Bacon espoused the scientific method. Creationism and ID are not suitable candidates for study based on the nature of the claim.

Belief in either ID or Spontaneous Generation origin theory (neither are yet proven and re-producible law) takes a leap of faith. What is unscientific about considering more than one origin theory? It appears that many SG advocates are emotionally invested in their origin theory, and this makes than uncomfortable with comparison beyond what they can demonstrate.  My personal observation of trends is that science is on the verge of proving ID of new life forms, and this makes SG 'experts' more than a little uncomfortable -- to the point of demanding censorship of ID origins theory. If ID presented testable and falsifiable hypotheses, it would be the object of scientific study; and, if the hypotheses were shown to be true, ID would become accepted on the evidence.  SG theory, as you call it, has many testable hypotheses.  For example, how are complex molecules made?  ID people say GOD created them.  What is the testable hypothesis?  None are offered.  Scientists propose that SG requires that early earth conditions should spontaneously yield complex molecules from simple ones.  Miller and Urey  did  the experiment by simulating early earth conditions in a test tube.  They exposed  water (H2O), methane (CH4), ammonia (NH3), and hydrogen (H2) (known early earth atmosphere and oceans) to an electric discharge (lightening).  A goo forms on the bottom of the test tube.  An analysis shows that it contains amino acids - the building blocks of life.  There are thousands of similar experiments that test various aspects of SG.  This is science.  ID is not.

There are at least a billion people who pay taxes and believe in Creationism....and you want their children to grow up ignorant of the implications of what they are supposed to believe? About there being two creation stories; have you heard of Einstein's twin brothers analogy? While it has its issues, those issues are not germane to it's analogy of the two creation stories. In my view both the evolution and creation narratives suffer from the concepts brought about by the twin brother analogy. Creationism IS a creation story and evolution, big bang cosmology, etc. IS science.  Teach science as science and Creationism as religion.  People can teach their children whatever they want, but in a science class, we are paying schools to teach science so that we can produce scientists who cure diseases, make our lives comfortable, and give us leisure to pursue our interests.  The money spent on science returns dividends that surpass the investment.  That is why we invest in science.

Parting Comments

People take advantage of what science produces but are uncomfortable when the knowledge gained conflicts with their religious beliefs.  The comments posted here testify to the respect that Science has won; everyone wants their beliefs to be associated with science as proof of their veracity.  Since Science carries so much weight, it is natural for Creationists and IDers to

push there agendas by forcing these topics into science classes.

Science, unlike people, is honest.  It is the best process to create an accurate representation of the material world that allows us to control nature and understand our origins.  The scientific method works best when its practitioners approach it without preconceived notions about how the world should be.  Forcing Creationism and ID into a Science curriculum corrupts the process and at its root is a dishonest act of self interest.

Those of you who think that banning the teaching of creationism is stifling free speech should read the decision of Judge Jones in the famous Dover case. He is a conservative christian appointed by Bush and gave the most impeccably logical arguments of why ID/creationism is not science and should be banned from being taught as science.

It's ironic that so many people use the argument that we can't disprove religion/creationism/ID so leave us alone and let it be taught in schools. This is exactly what makes religion/creationism/ID not science so it should not be taught as such.

The bottom line is that we are wasting precious classroom time teaching non-science that should be dedicated to teaching science; and in the process making students willfully ignorant citizens who will not believe that HIV is real, that vaccines cause autism, and that climate change must be a conspiracy because it snowed in my backyard.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Illogical Scientists

I know that I am often illogical about lots of things; it's a trait that makes us human. However, this does not excuse sloppy thinking by scientists. Scientists often complain about the innumeracy of the general population, but we are the most egregious offenders by associating undue meaning to the numbers, such as our reliance on the h-index to quantify the performance of an individual researcher with a single number.

The h-index is a measure based on citations to a researcher's work. The Wikipedia page on the h-index gives a description of how it is computed, what it purportedly measures, and criticisms of its use. No one would disagree that there are many factors that affect the h-index, making it a highly inaccurate metric. So, why do so many people use it? I believe that it is sheer intellectual laziness. What could be simpler than using a single number for ranking a group of individuals?

One of my beefs with the h-index is that it favors scientists that manage large research groups that publish lots of papers and produce lots of PhD s who then get jobs doing similar work and generate more citations for their research adviser. Is it healthy to reward good managers of science for being good scientists? Perhaps.

Scientists are well aware of the importance of their own h-index on career advancement. It is all too common for reviewers to point out that some important references are missing in a manuscript. As you might guess, reviewers often push for their own publications to be cited. Placing such a high degree of importance on a single indicator has a perverse effect on the scientific enterprise.

Perhaps I am selfish, but I live to think and to produce new ideas. It makes me happy. I want to be in the trenches, scribbling equations with my mechanical pencil on smooth white sheets of paper and tinkering in the lab with neat equipment that I have designed and build with my own hands - all in the company of students who are excitedly doing the same. I understand that there needs to be a balance between managing a lab and doing the work. A PI who spends all the time working in the lab is not passing along his or her expertise to others. It is also inefficient to be involved with all the mundane activities that go along with doing research. More ideas can be investigated when the students have a large degree of autonomy, so while difficult, I try to keep a healthy distance.

On the other extreme is the professor who writes lots of huge grant proposals and uses his or her mega funding to hire an army of postdocs who generate a large chunk of the ideas, advise the graduate students, and implement the work. Such an individual is doing a service to society by concentrating a critical mass of intellectual capital to solve important problems. It is an efficient division of labor where grantsmanship brings in the funds and the most capable people do the work.

I want to make it clear that I am not criticizing the big research groups. They provide an important service to the scientific community of producing the next generation of scientists and adding substantially to the knowledge base. Given that some of my work is amenable to large-scale science, I often question my decision to limit the size of my research group. Am I letting down my employer by bringing in a few hundred thousand dollars of funding per year rather than millions? My decision to operate on a smaller scale is based on my conviction that my science produces value to both the university and to society. Arguably, my group produces more publications and more citations per research dollars than many others. Imagine if a researcher's productivity were measured in citations per dollar of funding.

If truth be told, I would be dissatisfied working in a field with hundreds of researchers who are working on a tiny piece of a puzzle. Rather, I derive satisfaction from thinking about things from a unique and broad perspective. As a result, I have far fewer colleagues doing similar work and my students, as a result, will have fewer job opportunities - unless our work leads to a breakthrough. But, I justify our work in my conviction that such work has the potential for making a large impact in the long term.

However, I am concerned that the emphasis on large research groups garnering huge research grants will squeeze out the smaller groups, where breakthroughs in new thinking are usually generated. Given the present-day economic challenges, researchers with larger grants will undoubtedly be held in even higher regard by their cash-strapped administration.

A second perversion of the scientific enterprise is recognition for simply publishing in a prestigious journal. The quality of a paper should be judged on its own merits, not by its venue. The viscous cycle is reinforced by "me too" papers that cite high-visibility journals to imply that the author's work is in an important research area.

Consider the work of Victor Veselago who in 1967 investigated the properties of materials with a negative refractive index. His work got little attention (and few citations for decades) until the recent explosion of research on meta materials, results of which are routinely published in Nature and in Science with sleek color graphics and exciting titles. Amongst the present-day superstars are their lesser-known brethren such as Veselago who are laying the foundations for future revolutions.

Recently, the program director of an agency that funds my work sent me the following email,

I am collecting information to prepare for my upcoming internal review and I am collecting interesting accomplishments for highlights. This request does not substitute the formal annual progress report specified in the grant document that is due at your grant anniversary date of each year. Please provide a (no more than) one page summary of the significant accomplishments and publications (such as Science or Nature publications) in your program...

Clearly, this program director deems it necessary to justify to his superiors his funding choices not necessarily based on the quality of the work, but on where the work is published. What I find more distressing is that scientists in increasing numbers believe that a publication in these high profile journals carries greater importance.

Many years ago, one of my colleagues suggested that I should package my work in a way to make it publishable in Science or Nature. I did not chose science as a career to focus on marketing. Rather, I am motivated on a daily basis by the promise of understanding something new about nature and to share my understanding with others who are similarly driven. Nothing beats the eager faces in the classroom, arguing with me about my rendition of nature's hidden treasures. Nor the excited chatter of my graduate students as they report on new results or insights. Even day-to-day difficulties bring to light the pleasures of seeking the truth. At the end of the day, the negative aspects of the scientific culture fade into the background, where they belong. But, on occasion, my bliss is interrupted by that unpleasant pang of realization that scientists hold positions that are not supported by reason. We should know better. Shame on us.

Friday, October 8, 2010

Science as art

Last May, I attended a conference in France at The Ecole normale supérieure de Cachan (ENS Cachan) to celebrate the 60th birthday of Joseph Zyss, a distinguished Physicist who has made many seminal contributions to the field of organic nonlinear optics. He is one of the founding scientists of this highly interdisciplinary field, which has moved into many new directions including such diverse topics as biomedical imaging and optical telecommunications.

In addition to many stimulating scientific talks, a special session was dedicated to Prof. Zyss's achievements. Several eminent scientists described his research contributions, and past students talked about the profound effect he has had on their careers and their lives.

Joseph Zyss is a multidimensional person who has many interests outside his profession; art and gourmet food. For fun, the organizers arranged for two invited talks devoted to the topics of art in science and the science of food. The culinary talk described the chemical basis for taste and touched on the interesting possibility of chemically synthesizing new foods.

The presentation on art was filled with reproductions of diverse art forms, making connections to science by juxtaposing works of art with mathematical structures and images of real physical systems. The talk ended with the implicit question, will art and science ever converge. My immediate reaction was that science is art.

Mathematics is the color pallet, clay, and media of Physics. While art pierces the soul through images and narrative to elicit emotion, science inspires a sense of awe and wonder directly through the intellect. A piece of art, such as the Pieta, represents a thing of beauty, exquisite in its execution -- recreating the artist's faith and passion. Science, in contrast, through its mathematical structure, encompasses all that is and can be in one grand yet simple set of theories that are intellectually beautiful, reflecting the ingenuity and imagination of generations of scientists.

A painting or a sculpture can recreate only one particular scene as a map portrays in miniature the geography of an area. In contrast, a theory represents everything. It is a kind of universal art that portrays all AND always. It has both predictive power and leads to a deep understanding of all things. To me, the most spiritually intense response comes from seeing the universe through the inner eye of science.

Professor Zyss is a scientist whose life has left and continues to leave many significant brush strokes on the fabric of science. Our ambitions draw each of us to the canvas in hopes that our mark will be permanent, tantalized by the beauty of what has already been revealed, in awe of the larger image that is slowly coming into focus. I am privileged to stand before the canvass, to marvel at its beauty, and to participate in humanity's efforts to leave a mark, even if my work gets covered over by those who follow.