Showing posts with label two-photon absorption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label two-photon absorption. Show all posts

Thursday, August 11, 2011

My voice from the past

A while ago, David Bradly, a reporter from ScienceBase had contacted me about a paper from my group on self healing in a molecule called AF455. He wrote a short news piece on our work. After the piece was posted, he contacted me with additional questions. In response, I shot him an email, which he posted in its entirety. This was back in April of 2007, more than 4 years into my past.

Just 5 minutes ago, I was searching for articles related to our research and ran across my email. I tend to write emails from the top of my head, without much editing, so it was eerie to see myself in an unguarded moment. In effect, it was my own voice form the past, real and uncensored. When writing for the public, as I do in papers and proposals - and even in this blog, I choose my wording carefully, though often not with good results. While you may not notice the tone, reading this email rekindles in me the excitement of discovery that I was feeling at that time. It is better than any diary entry.

I am glad that David Bradley posted this email, which is truly a window into my past. It is reproduced below. As you may have guessed, he asked me about applications of our work.

Dear David,

The molecule AF455 is indeed complex, and that is what makes its irreversibility so puzzling. The DO11 dye, which we previously studied for reversibility is a relatively small molecule; and, the mechanisms for the recovery is the breaking up of dimers that form in the degradation process. This requires the molecules to be able to move around a bit. AF455 clearly can not move around easily, so another mechanism must be responsible.

Any device that operates at high intensity, such as lasers, displays, and all-optical switches and logic, suffer from photodegradation. Solid state lasers, for example, live longer than ion lasers and dye lasers; but, dye lasers have much more flexibility is the range of colors that are available. Polymer displays, on the other hand can be mechanically flexible and can be used to host all sorts of organic molecules. The general theme is that organic molecules have a much broader pallet of what they can do, but, they are not as stable.

So in our work, we are not so much interested in targeting specific applications. Rather, we want to understand the mechanisms for recovery since most materials degrade irreversibly. And here we have two very different molecules that behave the same way. There is one similarity. We discovered this property by accident!

If a material absorbs light strongly, it will damage when the absorbed optical power reaches the material's damage threshold. In applications where the material is transparent, light can be absorbed through a two-photon absorption process. Not as much light is absorbed in the process, but, over long-enough periods of time, cumulative effects cause the material to degrade.

Bright light can cause all sorts of things to happen in a material. If it induces a chemical reaction that causes a molecule to break apart into pieces, that process is irreversible. On the other hand, if the light causes the molecules to change shape into a form that no longer absorbs light or perhaps causes some charge to jump from one side of the molecule to the other, this change is reversible. The trick is to find materials that are not killed by the zap of laser, but that prefer to take a nap.

Another intriguing observation is that when such molecules wear out, rest, then recover many times, they seem to degrade more slowly and recover to a higher level of efficiency upon further cycling. It's like a weight lifter that gets stronger after each workout. So, it may be possible to make our molecules more buff by giving them a good workout. We observed this kind of response in the DO11 dye, but have not seen it in the AF455 dye.

So, while we see two-photon absorption (TPA) as a universal nuisance that destroys materials, and that's the motivation for our studies, there are many important applications. Two-photon absorption is strongest where the light intensity is the highest, and is ideal in applications where a chemical reaction in a material operates above a certain threshold power. The important consideration is that for absorption to occur, two photons must participate.

Cancer therapies are one such application. The patient drinks a cocktail of molecules that like to stick to a particular type of tumor cell. Also, these molecules are tailored to be strong two-photon absorbers to a color of light to which cells and flesh are transparent. Then, just aim a laser beam at the tumor right through the skin. In this way, only the tumor cells are zapped. Since the skin is not perfectly transparent, it will also absorb some of this light, causing a bit of damage. Ideally, you want to make the strength of two-photon absorption as high as possible so that the amount of damage to the tumor is as big as possible relative to the damage to healthy cells. You want the special molecules to live as long as possible so that they can be repeatedly zapped without the patient having to ingest more of the cocktail, which could have side effects.

Since TPA is a process where two photons are simultaneously absorbed, it can be used to drive chemical reactions at the intersection point of two beams of light. As an example, a liquid can be made to turn solid (i.e. polymerize) at the crossing points. In this way, a three-dimensional object can be made piece by piece inside the liquid, such as gears, shafts, and other nano-scale parts. So, it's like having the ultimate nanolab.

So, TPA is something that is simultaneously very useful in important applications; but, can be a nuisance in all applications that require the use of light. We are thinking more about ways to make a molecule snooze to help it recover rather than find more ways to put it to work. Happy dreams!

Mark

Saturday, November 20, 2010

Simple Scaling and too much to do in too little time

This was a good week. Nathan successfully defended his dissertation with flying colors and our manuscript for Advanced Materials, a high impact journal, was accepted. Our paper is a comment on another paper that previously appeared in Advanced Materials.

One central theme of our work that uses fundamental limits and sum rules to understand the nonlinear-optical response is the idea of scale invariance. The Schrodinger Equation has the property that the shape of the wavefunction does not change when the width of the potential energy function is decreased by a scaling factor b and the depth of the well is simultaneously increased by b squared. Under such a transformation, the wavefunction is compressed by the factor b, but otherwise, the shape remains the same. We call this simple scaling.

The nonlinear-optical quantity of interest to many applications is called the hyperpolarizability. Making the hyperpolarizability as large as possible is an ongoing area of intense research activity. To nobody's surprise, a larger molecule will generally have a larger hyperpolarizability. To better understand what makes a material tick, we have defined a quantity called the intrinsic hyperpolarizability, which is simply the ratio of the hyperpolarizability of a quantum system, divided by the fundamental limit. Interestingly, the intrinsic hyperpolarizability is invariant under simple scaling, so large and small molecules that are related to each other by simple scaling will have the same intrinsic hyperpolarizability.

In examining all the molecules that had been studied for nonlinear-optical applications over a 3 decade period, we found that the large range of hyperpolarizability values could mostly be accounted for by simple scaling. Thus, researchers were making molecules larger and larger but the best intrinsic hyperpolarizabilities remained static at about 0.03 - suggesting that it would be possible to make a factor of 30 improvement; but to get there would undoubtedly requrie a major paradigm shift.

Several years ago, I published a paper that showed how to calculate a related quantity called the intrinsic two-photon absorption (TPA) cross-section. More recently, Javier Perez-Moreno and I published a paper that introduced a rough rule of thumb for determining the intrinsic TPA cross-section - simply divide it by the square of the number of electrons. My earlier paper showed how to determine the number of electrons.

To my delight, my paper on TPA gets lots of citations, not because of what I believe is the beautiful physics of the work, but because scientists refer to my method of counting the number of effective electrons - a quite trivial (and approximate) procedure. To my horror, when comparing molecules, most researchers then go on to divide by the number of electrons rather than by the square of the number of electrons as suggested by Javier's work. This leads to a flawed comparison between molecules.

A recent paper in Advanced Materials reported on TPA cross section measurements of a new class of dendrimers, molecules with ever-branching pieces much like veins and arteries. They referred to my paper when calculating the number of electrons; but, as is usually the case, they divided by the number of electrons and found that the new dendrimer class was an order of magnitude better than the best existing dendrimers - an impressive improvement.

In our comment on this paper, we reanalyzed the data using the N squared rule and found that the new materials were in fact two orders of magnitude better. In addition, the dendrimers within each class, though of vastly differing sizes, all had approximately the same intrinsic TPA cross section. Thus, we were able to show that the authors had made an even more important discovery than they had realized. Usually, comments on a paper point out a negative flaw, leading to strong rebuttals and counter-rebuttals. In this case, all parties were winners.

Unfortunately, these small successes were overshadowed by a pile of work. After the Thanksgiving break, I am going to an NSF meeting in Hawaii (I hate to travel and I hate hot and humid places), where I will be reporting on the results of our projects. I need to prepare a glitzy poster as well as an oral presentation. This, on top of being hopelessly behind in preparing problem sets/solutions, grading, and catching up on lectures for my graduate mechanics class. In addition, I need to write a pile of recommendations and read a 350 page dissertation; the defense will take place early Monday morning.

Smack in the middle of this stressful week, after months of waiting for an estimate, a flooring contractor handed us an estimate and told us that he could get new floors in before Thanksgiving. Things moved fast, requiring us to immediately move large and heavy furniture back and forth between two rooms, which included taking down built-in cabinets and then replacing them, as well painting all the walls. After spending three solid days on manual labor (actually a satisfying break from work), my time pressures have become critical. I cringe at the accumulating piles of manuscripts waiting to be written and the papers that I need to review for journals.

So, how did I handle the stress? I squandered a couple hours writing about my frustrations on this blog. And now, back to work...