Showing posts with label quantum wires. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quantum wires. Show all posts

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Kicking Around New Ideas

For a couple months now, we have been struggling with calculations of the nonlinear-optical response of quantum wires. Our idea is to build up complex structures by connecting together pieces of straight wire segments. The problem is that the sum rules appear to have pathologies. But in reality, the problems lie in the way that we idealize the wire.

As I discussed in a previous post, the case of the quantum rotor is a specific example that had been treated rigorously by Stavros Fallieros. I had an idea of how to apply a similar argument to a straight section of wire. The upshot is that along a wire, the sum rules hold. The problem with an idealized one-dimensional wire is that the wave function is by definition confined to the wire, and therefore vanishes outside. By the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, a particle that is confined in that way must have an infinite transverse momentum, implying an infinite energy state.

If these infinite energy states are included, the sum rules are obeyed. I came up with a simple textbook approach that models transverse confinement with a Dirac delta function potential in the limit when the strength of the delta function is infinite. While I had not solved the full problem, I wrote up the concept in a file LaTeX where I wrote out the form of the solutions. Then, I passed the document along to my students for them to do the hard part: evaluating infinite sums of complicated expressions in the limit when various parameters are large and small. Since there are no loopholes in the way the sum rules are derived, I am confident that this approach will work.

The other day, after I emailed this file to the students, we had a spirited debate. They disagreed with my approach and gave all sorts of counterarguments to prove me wring. They constructed special cases that seemed airtight arguments against my approach. But slowly, they became convinced; not because I am the expert, but because my argument is sound. This is one of the most satisfying aspects of the community of science. In the end, reason wins. This time, I may have been vindicated, but I have made enough mistakes in the past to not be overly dejected when I am proven wrong. Being scientists requires us to admit error.

As an update to one of our papers that was initially rejected, in the process of responding to a substantive comment made by one of the reviewers, David Watkins found an intrinsic hyperpolarizability that exceeds unity - an impossibility, according to my theory. Though my theory has been tested over an over again using different computational techniques under a broad range of conditions, I panic when it appears that I might have missed something. David and I sent many emails back and forth on the topic, trying to understand if somehow the sum rules were being violated by the new case under study. To my delight, David found and fixed a couple of bugs in his code, which solved the problem. The results for this new case is now consistent with all our other calculations.

On another front, three students from my nonlinear optics class and I had finished a nice paper on cascading at the beginning of the summer. As I had reported in a previous post, just prior to submitting the paper, we had found a case where the fundamental limits were exceeded. Since then, we have tried all sorts of approaches to reconcile the problem, but to no avail. Nathan, the lead student on the project, believes that cascading is a way to beat the limits. However, based on general principles, I know the limits must hold. And it's not that I want my theory to be true, but, based on general arguments, the cascading results - which are a special case - must agree with the more general theory. If a specific case appears to violate the more general one, it is incumbent upon us to track down the source of the inconsistency. In other words, we have to specifically show how this case falls outside the realm of the theory. At this point, cascading seems to be formulated in a way that makes it a simple subset of the more general theory.

I have been writing much about theory, but our experimental work has been going well. Shiva has built a beautiful temperature-controlled chamber that will allow him to do experiments from temperatures well bellow ambient to over 100 C. Since the temperature-dependence of a measurement provides a window into the energetics of a process, we hope the new experiments will provide us with a clue as to the metastable species involved that usher self heal self healing of a molecule upon photodegradation. In parallel, I am trying to work out a general theory of self-healing based on our past observations. The real test of this theory will be its power to predict the behavior of new observations as better experiments push the envelope of our knowledge. As a sneak preview, the theory includes a recovery process that is akin to stimulated emission, but in the case of dye recovery, has to do with coupling between the guest molecules and phonons in the host polymer.

Prabodh, a new graduate student in our group is specializing in making a large variety of samples so that he can study how the dopant and polymer host affect the healing process. Ben is doing a a series of experiments to optically image the damaged areas to better pin down the population dynamics, and he is building a new experiment that will allow us to determine the absorption spectrum at each point in the damage region. The combination of new samples and new measurements will provide valuable complimentary data that will undoubtedly aid us in unraveling the puzzle of self healing.

Nathan is getting additional data on the photomechanical response that appears to be consistent with our models. While the results are giving us insights into the new class of liquid crystal elastomeric materials, our conclusions appear to be at odds with those of our collaborators, who supplied us with the samples. I am confident that we will eventually reach a consensus because the truth always bubbles to the top. Even if we are proven right, we most likely have only part of the answer. More interesting mysteries are undoubtedly lurking at the next layer of depth.

Xianjun is in the process of calculating the response of Photomechanical Optical Devices (PODs), with the goal of predicting how they will behave when acting in series. This is a highly nonlinear problem, with complex solutions. At this stage, we are still struggling with the relatively simple things, like the response of a single nonlinear etalon. More complex systems will require us to consider more subtle issues and to be clever in our approximations to solving the full problem. In parallel, Xianjun is starting experiments to burn Bgragg gratings in polymer optical fibers with the goal of making and characterizing PODs. Measurements will play an indispensable part in developing our numerical models.

I hve more to write, but our flight to Amsterdam is boarding. This long trip will eventually lead us to Budapest, where I am giving a plenary lecture on self healing and photo mechanical effects. I apologize for any typos that resulted from my haste, and will write about the meeting upon my return.

Friday, July 16, 2010

Sum Rules

I just skimmed over the paper by Stavros Fallieros. In those 15 minutes, I learned something new, which I shared in an email to my students. Below is the email, with typos and all.


I have just read the papers sent to me by Shoresh on the rigid rotator. My analysis of those papers in light of our work is as follows.


These papers show that the sum rules cannot be violated. As we know, for a given potential, there can be both bound states and free states. Since the sum rules require one to sum over all these states, summing over just a subset gives the wrong result.

In the case of a rigid rotator, the wavefunctions are confined to a wire loop (or attached with a rigid rod, the problem is equivalent). If one starts with a wire loop that is represented by a non-infinite potential so that the wavefunction can spill out of the loop, there are free and bound states. In this case, it is simple to sum over all states and the sum rules are obeyed yielding unity for the (0,0) sum rule.

When the electron is confined to the wire, which can be approximated as the limiting case of a delta function shell, the free states are pushed away to infinite energy. If one includes these infinite-energy states in the sum rules, all is well and the (0,0) sum rule is still obeyed. However, when not accounting for the free states by use of the limiting case, the free states are missed and the sum rules give 2/3 instead of 1. So, the problem is not that the sum rules need to be generalized or that they are being violated, but that we are not taking into account all the states as required by the sum rules. The easiest way to deal with this issue is to just throw in the factor of 1/3 to account for the bound states at infinite energy, which are otherwise difficult determine when starting from the idealized quantum wire.

Now to Shoresh's problem. In our calculations, we get the result that just two terms exceed the sum rules. Since all of the terms are positive definitive, there is no way that missed states can fix the problem. They will only make the sum rule violation problem bigger. So, I still think that there is a problem with the calculation that needs to be traced. In the end, when applying the sum rules, we should get a result that is less than unity.

Once we are certain that our formulation is correct, it will be interesting to see how the issues with infinite energy states affect the off-diagonal sum rules. The upshot is that if the off-diagonal sum rules give nonzero sums, then the dipole-free expression will give the wrong result. However, if we can determine the effect of the infinite energy states on the sum rules, we can reformulate the dipole-free form to make it work in these special cases.

We still need to fix the betaDF and betaSOS code. Perhaps Julian can concentrate on this problem while Shoresh works on the sum rules.

Thursday, July 15, 2010

The consistency of physics

Most of my entries are not quite in the form of a diary as I had planned. However, my posts reflect the fact that I spend lots of time thinking about things, so I argue that these are genuine diary entries. But at least for today, my entry will be more diary-like

When I made my rounds in the lab this afternoon, I noticed a common theme in my discussions with the students -- the amazing consistency of physics. Physics covers a broad range of phenomena (everything in the universe obeys the laws of physics!) that mesh together in the most beautiful ways.

My first stop was the department office on the 12th floor to sign paperwork. In the most recent power change, I once again avoided chairing the department, but as a comprise, I agreed to be the associate chair for a year -- the same deal I had made 8 years ago. But, my true pleasures awaited me on the 7th floor, the location of my labs.

First, I spent time talking with Julian, an undergraduate student, and Shoresh, a graduate student, who are using sum rules as a guide to developing theories of the relationship between the geometry of quantum nanowires and their nonlinear-optical properties. What started out as a simple class project has evolved into a huge undertaking. New subtleties keep popping up. Last week we had to revisit the basics of expectation values of quantum mechanics when applied to loops of wires. The fact that the answers that we are getting continue to be inconstant with the sum rules is a sure sign that we are getting something wrong.

Since sum rules are derived directly from the Schrodinger equation with no approximation, they cannot be violated. About an hour of discussions on the topic led to some new ideas and new approaches that will help us better understand our problems, which hopefully will lead to a solution. While constantly tracing errors in theoretical models is highly unpleasant, the exhilaration of learning makes it all worthwhile. Michael Cohen, a student of Feynman's and a professor of mine at U Penn showed me the value of going back to the basics and testing the assumptions, no matter how trivial. The process always leads to a deeper understanding.

Next I went to Nathan's office, a student who is doing work that we hope will someday lead to ultra-smart materials. After I helped him and Xianjun clean some laser optics, Nathan described his ambiguous experimental results of the previous evening. Then we returned to his office to discuss another project that we had started in nonlinear optics class. He and two of his classmates did calculations to understand if the process of cascading could be used to break the fundamental limits of the nonlinear optical response that I had calculated 10 years prior. Since my calculations were fairly general, I did not believe this to be possible; but, we are obligated to test the hypothesis. Cascading appears to be a topic of growing interest in the nonlinear optics community because of the new avenues it may provide for making better materials. Our work will assess its usefulness and may lead to design guidelines for new nonlinear-optical material paradigms.

There were several false starts - calculations that gave infinities or calculations that yielded limiting cases that were inconsistent with known physics. After a couple of weeks, and many discussions, we finally converged to what appeared to be a robust theory of cascading. After receiving a draft manuscript from the students, I spent several days adding lots of new material, expanding the bibliography, as well as correcting lots of little errors. Just as I was applying the finishing touches in smug satisfaction of the beauty of the final product, I noticed that we failed to consider one important case. So, I sent Nathan an email, and he went back to the drawing board.

Again, the infinities reared their ugly heads. Luckily, my 2006 paper provided us with some guidance. Nathan concluded that indeed, he could remove the infinities with this method; but, again, there are many subtleties and ambiguities regarding the formulation of the model. After a brief discussion, we agreed on an approach and Nathan immediately began implementing the calculations.

Almost 10 years ago, one of my students and I discovered that some materials self heal after photodegradation. This was an exciting discovery because of the apparent reversal of the arrow of time. The result is yet to be fully understood. Three students are presently working on the project. This work requires lots of samples to be made, long experiments that can take several days of continuous operation, and complex analysis of huge data files. Some of these experiments are currently up and running while we are in the planning phases of building a new instrument and upgrading some older experiments.

The experimental results are encouraging but continue to throw more puzzles our way than providing reliable tests of our hypotheses. But, I have a good feeling that we are expanding into new experimental techniques that will hopefully provide lots of answers as well enabling us to pose more interesting new questions.

When I got home from the lab, my inbox had a message labeled "important." Shoresh had found a paper that shed light on our observation of sum rule violation. The paper's abstract was short but to the point, "We discuss application of the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule to simple quantum-mechanical models and its apparent violation by the rigid rotator."

Scanning through the paper, I noticed that the first reference in the bibliography was coauthored by Stavros Fallieros -- an incredible coincidence considering that my parents bought his house in 1968 when I was 10 years old. There must have been the essence of sum rules in the walls that were infused into my being during adolescence.

As it turns out, my in-laws were good friends with the Fallieros family, and continued to remain in touch. Several years after I wrote my 2000 paper on fundamental limits, my wife was visiting her mother in a suburb of Philadelphia, where she ran into Stavros. During the exchange of pleasantries, he learned about our common interest in sum rules, and relayed through my wife the message that he wanted a copy of my paper, which I happily mailed to him. Unfortunately, he passed away soon after, and we never had a chance to discuss the work. Ironically, the sum rule paper that he wrote, and which I recently found, was his last journal publication. With the perfect symmetry not often found in life, one of the last papers that he had in his possession was my paper on sum rules.

The interconnectedness of science is mirrored in the relationships between scientists. We are each small cogs in a gargantuan machine that produces new knowledge. One of my former graduate students, Xavi (PhD in 2007), who was the first person to appreciate my use of the sum rules in nonlinear optics will be visiting my group for 6 weeks this summer. Later in the summer, his co-advisor will also be visitng from Belgium. This combination of our two visitors, a new student in my group, Sengting, who is following in the footsteps of Xavi in his pursuit of a joint PhD degree between WSU and the University of Leuven, along with Shoresh and Julian provides us with a formidable crew that will undoubtedly add to the knowledge base of science.

As I sit here at my computer in this small pocket of nostalgic bliss, thinking about international collaborations and our connections with past and future science, I am looking forward to the satisfaction of learning new things as well as tracking divergences in calculations, fixing lasers, and deficit spending to buy components for a new experiments. Another typical day begins!